Low-Income Tenants in Staten Island Shocked as Evictions Filed Over $5,000 in Back Rent

Low-income tenants in Staten Island, New York, are unexpectedly facing eviction for unpaid rent, including balances as low as $5,000.
This situation has stirred controversy and debate, shedding light on the challenges faced by landlords in the current rental landscape.
The story revolves around Renova Properties, a subsidiary of Cab’s International Group, which owns a large housing complex in New Dorp, Staten Island. Since the statewide freeze on most evictions was lifted in January 2022, Renova Properties has initiated a staggering 169 eviction cases against tenants residing at Tyson’s Park Apartments.

What makes this situation remarkable is that many of the eviction cases target tenants with rent subsidies or vouchers administered by the Department of Social Services. In at least 23 identified instances, the landlord moved forward with eviction procedures due to unpaid portions of rent meant to be covered by these social welfare programs.

The landlord’s swift action in filing eviction notices has sparked a heated debate. While some argue that the tenants’ entitlement and dependency on government assistance are concerning, others see it as a reflection of broader issues in the rental system.
To provide some context, Renova Properties manages an extensive complex with 1,106 units, making it one of the largest landlords in New Dorp. Out of these 1,106 units, only 26 have witnessed successful evictions since 2022. This fact highlights that the majority of tenants are fulfilling their rental obligations.

However, tenants and their advocates point to two main issues contributing to the spike in eviction cases. They claim that Renova Properties’ property manager employs a quick eviction and debt collection strategy, and bureaucratic delays on the part of the Department of Social Services are causing delays in the timely disbursement of rental payments to landlords.
Notably, a review of court records shows that tenants who received eviction notices at Tyson’s Park owed a median amount of $471 each, totaling nearly $900,000 in unpaid rent. Only 13 out of the 169 households sued by Renova owed more than $9,000, with another 40 owing less than $3,500.

Monthly rents at Tyson’s Park Apartments range from approximately $900 for long-term tenants in rent-stabilized units to around $2,500.This situation in Staten Island has sparked a broader discussion about tenants’ rights, landlord responsibilities, and the challenges inherent in the rental landscape. While some argue for the importance of prompt eviction procedures to protect landlords’ interests, others raise concerns about tenant vulnerabilities in the current rental market.
In conclusion, this story highlights the intricate relationship between economic factors, tenant dependency on government aid, and the difficulties landlords encounter in property management.

Scroll to Top